Katt's YouTube
Tip Katt
Chronological Timeline — Brendan Banfield Trial
February 23–24, 2023
Thursday, February 23, 2023
9:25–10:55 PM
Christine's laptop - Chrome searches related to resorts (DE321, DE332)
9:25–9:51 PM (With gap in activity until ~ 11:00 PM)
Christine's phone actively used for communications/messaging (DE333, DE320)
9:35:47 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "sorry I couldn't get online yesterday" (CW 73)
9:36:05 PM
Telegram: Annastasia sends home address (CW 73
9:36:27 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "Looks like you are ready!!" (CW 73)
9:36:31 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "I'm ready!!!" (CW 73)
9:51 PM–~11:00 PM
Gap in Christine's phone activity
10:46:52 PM
Telegram: Joe - Read Receipt (CW 73)
10:59:42–11:49:47 PM
Telegram app open and active on Christine's laptop (DE337)
10:59:58 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "I'm back" (CW 73)
11:00:26 PM
Telegram: Joe: "Hey. I just saw your message" (CW 73)
11:00:57 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "How are you tonight?" (CW 73)
11:01:12 PM
Telegram: Joe reacts to address ("made my heart beat faster") (CW 73)
11:01:17 PM
Telegram: Annastasia asks travel time (CW 73)
11:01:25 PM
Telegram: Joe: "25 minutes." (CW 73)
11:02:14 PM
Telegram: Joe: "I'm very ready." (CW 73)
11:06:11 PM
Telegram: Joe: "I've gathered everything together tonight…" (CW 73)
11:07:13 PM
Telegram: Joe asks about parking (CW 73)
11:08:43 PM
Telegram: Joe asks whether to wait or be messaged (CW 73)
11:09:06 PM
Telegram: Joe: "7:15?" (CW 73)
11:12:00 PM
Juliana's FB messenger is in use~ (Lidsky Testimony)
11:15:52 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "I'll message you in the morning…" (CW 73)
11:17:47 PM
Telegram: Joe discusses stomping/kicking as signal (CW 73)
11:21:39 PM
Telegram: Joe: "I can just restrain you with chains…" (CW 73)
11:22:54 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "I want to fully experience the scene" (CW 73)
11:27:14 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "Lets say 10:30" (CW 73)
11:29:29 PM
Telegram: Annastasia requests ETA message (CW 73)
11:29:57 PM
Telegram: Annastasia: "Aim for 7:20" (CW 73)
11:30:45 PM
Telegram: Joe: "I'll be in the area a little early" (CW 73)
11:32:27 PM
Telegram: Joe references nearby Walmart (CW 73)
11:37:31 PM
Telegram: Joe: "7.5 hours from now" (CW 73)
11:49:32 PM
Telegram: Joe: "Goodnight" (CW 73)
11:49:43 PM
Telegram read receipt logged (CW 73)
Exhibits
DE 321
DE 320
DE 332
DE 333
CW 73 (Telegram Messages; Cellebrite Extraction from Joseph Ryan's Phone)
Friday, February 24, 2023
6:03:44 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "Good morning!" (CW 73)
6:04:13 AM
Telegram: Joe: "Good to see you up" (CW 73)
6:04:47 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "Couldn't sleep too excited!" (CW 73)
6:05:16 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "How are you?" (CW 73)
6:06:01 AM
Telegram: Joe: "Drinking my coffee before I head over" (CW 73)
6:09:15 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "I'm waiting for you" (CW 73)
6:09:33 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "I'm definitely ready!" (CW 73)
6:10:54 AM
Telegram: Joe: "You'll be bent over my knee in about a hour" (CW 73)
6:11:55 AM
Telegram: Annastasia requests departure + ETA (CW 73)
6:14:35 AM
Telegram: Joe says he's stopping at Walmart; drive ~30 minutes (CW 73)
6:15:47 AM
Telegram: Joe asks about extra supplies (CW 73; 11:15:47 AM UTC)
6:16:35 AM
Telegram: Annastasia responds re lube (CW 73)
6:17:17–6:19:10 AM
Telegram: Joe confirms he'll grab supplies; mentions items packed (CW 73)
6:19:15 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "You're the best :)" (CW 73)
6:24:05 AM
Telegram: Joe: "Leaving in 10ish… 7:20–7:30" (CW 73)
6:25:25 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "see you soon" (CW 73)
6:26 AM
Juliana phone/watch movement begins (Source: extraction/testimony)
6:27 AM
Juliana device user unlock recorded (Source: Lidsky extraction testimony)
6:34:54 AM
Telegram: Joe: "Do some stretching" (CW 73)
6:35:12 AM
Telegram: Joe: "Leaving now" (CW 73)
6:37:28 AM
Telegram: Joe: "7:30 ETA. Traffic!" (CW 73)
6:46 AM
Christine Banfield's phone powers down (Source: extraction/testimony; CW209 per notes)
6:48:03 AM
Telegram: Annastasia: "Ok, I'll be waiting for you" (Source: CW 73; 11:48:03 AM UTC)
~7:21 AM
McDonald's order placed (Source: McDonald's footage notes)
7:23:36–7:24:09 AM
15 Apple Watch steps recorded (Source: Def Ex 358 / Magnet AXIOM)
~7:37 AM
Leaves McDonald's while on phone (Source: McDonald's footage notes)
~7:37:37 AM
Still on phone entering vehicle (Source: McDonald's footage notes)
7:36 AM
Outgoing call to Christine (5 sec) (Source: CW 233b)
7:37 AM
Outgoing call to Brendan (19 sec) (Source: CW 233c)
7:38 AM
Incoming call from Brendan (47 sec) (Source: CW 233c)
7:37 AM
Brendan Android call log: Juliana Au Pair (Source: CW 232a)
7:38 AM
Brendan Android call log: Christine Banfield (Source: CW 232a)
7:38 AM
Brendan Android call log: Juliana Au Pair (Source: CW 232a)
7:41:22 AM
Juliana device logs "parked" event (Source: extraction/testimony)
7:42 AM
Brendan Android call log: Christine Banfield (2) (Source: CW 232a)
7:43:37 AM
Juliana Apple Watch steps resume (Source: extraction/testimony)
7:47 AM
Outgoing 911 call (7 sec) (Source: CW 233d)
7:47 AM
Missed 911 call-back from +1 (703) 877-3038 (Source: CW 233e)
7:48 AM
Canceled 911 call (Source: CW 233f)
7:49 AM
Canceled 911 call (Source: CW 233f)
8:02 AM
911 call connected (8 minutes) (Source: CW 233f)
8:37 AM
Brendan Android call log: Rupa Reeon's Mom (Source: CW 232a)
10:06 AM
Brendan Android missed call: Amanda Au Pair (Source: CW 232a)
10:40 AM
Brendan Android missed call: Thomas Allen (Source: CW 232a)
Exhibits
Topical Timeline — Brendan Banfield Trial
February 23–24, 2023
Thursday, February 23, 2023
Evening (general)
Punta Cana trip planning; dinner at Korean BBQ with Christine + Valerie; friend Nishant drops off midnight cookies — normal household activity (Source: Brendan Banfield testimony / notes)
9:25–10:55 PM
Messaging + Chrome search activity for resorts on Christine's phone (DE330–333)
9:25–9:51 PM
Christine's phone actively used for communications/messaging (DE333, DE320)
9:34–10:55 PM
Christine's laptop in use; resort/vacation searches (DE321, DE332)
9:51–~11:00 PM
Phone activity gap on Christine's device
10:59:42–11:49:47 PM
Telegram app open and active on laptop (DE337)
Telegram Messages — Laptop Activity (UTC converted to local)
(Source: CW 73)
9:35:47 PM
Annastasia: "sorry I couldn't get online yesterday"
9:36:05 PM
Annastasia sends home address
9:36:27 PM
Annastasia: "Looks like you are ready!!"
9:36:31 PM
Annastasia: "I'm ready!!!"
10:46:52 PM
Joe message logged (content not shown in export)
11:00:26 PM
Joe: "Hey. I just saw your message"
11:01:12 PM
Joe reacts to seeing address ("heart beat faster")
11:01:25 PM
Joe states travel time: "25 minutes"
11:07–11:09 PM
Joe discusses parking and arrival timing ("7:15?" / "7:30?")
11:29:57 PM
Annastasia: "Aim for 7:20"
11:30:45 PM
Joe: "I'll be in the area a little early"
11:32:27 PM
Joe references nearby Walmart stop
11:37:31 PM
Joe: "7.5 hours from now"
11:49:32 PM
Joe: "Goodnight"
11:49:43 PM
Read receipt recorded
Friday, February 24, 2023
Early Morning — Telegram (departure/travel planning)
(Source: CW 73; UTC converted)
6:03:44 AM
Annastasia: "Good morning!"
6:06:01 AM
Joe: "Drinking my coffee before I head over"
6:10:54 AM
Joe: "You'll be bent over my knee in about a hour"
6:14:35 AM
Joe: Walmart stop for supplies; states drive is ~30 minutes
6:24:05 AM
Joe: "Leaving in 10ish. Won't show up until 7:20–7:30"
6:34:54 AM
Joe: "Do some stretching"
6:35:12 AM
Joe: "Leaving now"
6:37:28 AM
Joe: "7:30 ETA. Traffic!"
6:48:03 AM
Annastasia: "Ok, I'll be waiting for you"
Device / Movement Activity
6:26 AM
Juliana phone/watch movement begins (steps/activity start) (Source: extraction testimony)
6:27 AM
Juliana device user unlock recorded (Source: extraction testimony)
6:46 AM
Christine Banfield's phone powers down (Source: extraction/testimony; noted earlier as CW209)
McDonald's Footage
  • ~7:21 AM — Arrival; Drive-Thru
  • ~7:37 AM — Leaves McDonald's while on phone
  • ~7:37:37 AM — Still on phone entering vehicle (Source: your notes/footage)
Apple Health / Watch
7:23:36–7:24:09 AM
15 steps recorded (Apple Watch steps) (Source: Def Ex 358 / Magnet AXIOM "Nanny Phone")
7:41:22 AM
"Parked" event logged
7:43:37 AM
Steps resume
Phone Call Activity — JPM iPhone (Juliana/house phone)
1
7:36 AM
Outgoing call to Christine (5 sec) (CW 233b)
2
7:37 AM
Outgoing call to Brendan (19 sec) (CW 233c)
3
7:38 AM
Incoming call from Brendan (47 sec) (CW 233c)
4
7:47 AM
Outgoing 911 call (7 sec) (CW 233d)
5
7:47 AM
911 call-back missed (+1 703-877-3038) (CW 233e)
6
7:48 AM
Canceled 911 call (CW 233f)
7
7:49 AM
Canceled 911 call (CW 233f)
8
8:02 AM
911 call connected (8 minutes) (CW 233f)
Phone Call Activity — Brendan Android Device
1
7:37 AM
Call: Juliana Au Pair
2
7:38 AM
Call: Christine Banfield
3
7:38 AM
Call: Juliana Au Pair
4
7:42 AM
Call: Christine Banfield (2)
5
8:37 AM
Call: Rupa Reeon's Mom
6
10:06 AM
Missed call: Amanda Au Pair
7
10:40 AM
Missed call: Thomas Allen